Deletion and modification seem to confuse students. Additive methods appear easier in my experience. Over the next few posts I wish to present a few tweaks I have used to get my students past sticking points whose existence I have struggled to understand since I was certain I had already broken it down to the simplest form. In my practice these tweaks have been extremely potent. I would like to hear about any other special fixes people have found for the other areas of difficulties.
I am not entirely happy about resorting to these techniques. The ability to use harder or conventional solving techniques is essential since not everything can be designed to be simpler. Alternative resources will use common methods rather that Mr. Masri’s Secret Recipe. However, we are all pressured to ensure our students pick up skills that will allow them to understand their subject, even if it means sidestepping basic cognition.
Part 1 : Balancing Chemical Equations
Even the explicit instructions written in large letters do not deter the students.
- DO NOT CHANGE THE SMALL NUMBERS
- DO NOT CHANGE THE LETTERS
- DO NOT ADD A NEW MOLECULE (this is sometime treated as a subset of changing letters)
I would stand right beside them and watch their furrowed brows. They were unable to see any new possibilities. This will happen even with worked examples, physical demonstrations, and electronic aids. They will cycle through these three options before finally committing one of these mistake.
I have known this for a while. Students will make the mistake even if they know it is wrong because it makes sense to them. 1
With modification baked into the method, the student has to remember a larger myriad of rule regarding sanctioned and unsanctioned modification. Adding a whole molecule to address an imbalance of a single atom seems inefficient. While I can get the students to agree to the basic precepts that what they are doing changes the reaction fundamentally the link between the concepts and the method remains perfunctory to all except the brightest.
Is it possible to bake into the method a recognition of this fact?
This was not a method I had developed myself. In retrospec is is incredibly obvious. My students had a for a very long time performed well on the PHET balancing equations simulation but failed miserably with the paper method.
I will compare solving it with the traditional method2 and with my newer method. I am also going to ignore the algebraic method
Comparing the methods
Consider the unbalanced equation
Typical method to balancing equation
1. List out the the elements. Count the atoms for each element and place inside the table.
Elements Reactants Products C 1 2 O 3 2 H 2 2 2.See which side has fewer atoms of one element than the other.
Notice that the are fewer carbons on the left hand side than the right hand side
3. Modify the equation. In this case add another CO2 by writing 2 in-front of it.
4. Modify your table to count these new atoms
Elements Reactants Products C 122 O 352 H 2 2 5. Repeat step 2 3 and 4 until both the reactants are product have the same number of atoms for each element.
2nd time round
Repeat 2. See which side has fewer atoms of one element than the other.
Notice that the are fewer oxygen atoms on the right hand side than the left hand side
Repeat 3. Modify the equation. In this case add 2 more O2 by writing 3 in-front of it
Repeat 4. Modify your table to count these new atoms
Elements Reactants Products C 122 O 3526H 2 2 Repeat 2. See which side has fewer atoms of one element than the other.
Notice that the are fewer oxygen atoms on the left hand side than the right hand side.
Repeat 3. Modify the equation. In this case there are two molecules that can provide the oxygen needed. Increasing either of them will break the current balance for C and H.
In cases it usually does not matter which you increase first because you will end up increasing both. A good rule is to do the one with an element that is not O or H.
Repeat 4. Modify your table to count these new atoms
Elements Reactants Products C 1232 O 357263rd time round
Elements Reactants Products C 12324O 35726H 2 244th time round
Elements Reactants Products C 123424O 357926H 2 245th time round
Elements Reactants Products C 123424O 35791026H 24246th time round
Elements Reactants Products C 123424O 3579102610H 24246. Write the final formula
There are 15 cancellations with this normal method. It is not a wonder someone non-confident students would question their technique. They are also required to keep swapping between the table and their formula repeatedly. There are also require to directly modify the line of the equation but only in a specified way. While this is quite simple it is part of a 6 step process.
Now lets see a different method that has fewer steps, eliminates any need for cancellation, requires no swapping and demonstrates the preservation of the reaction.
Column Balancing Method
1. Look at the elements and count and see which side has less. Whichever side has less, add another of that whole molecule. In this case there are fewer carbons on the left so write the whole molecule that has carbon in it again below.
2. Repeat step 1 until neither side has fewer atoms.
2nd time round
Repeat Step 1
In this case carbons are balanced but there are fewer oxygen on the right hand side.
3rd time round
Repeat Step 1
In this case carbons are balance but there are fewer oxygen on the left hand side. A smarter student might be able to see adding another CO2 will keep this discrepancy of odd and even number of O but it does not matter.
4th time round
5th time round
6th time round
3. Write the final Formula
It is an advantage in almost every single way. Number of cancellations zero. Focus is always on the same construct. No modification to cascade through to a separate construct. Assuming the page is large enough, there is no running out of space because the original formula/table was written too narrowly spaced.
I am not satisfied with the fact that what I consider a reasonable method is a constant source of confusion for many students. Even when breaking it down and demonstrating the relative complexity between these two methods it should be within the capacity of any student to NOT change the molecules. The skill to follow instructions is entirely side stepped so cognitive development is ignored. However, now the student is able to progress in chemistry with a method that structurally reflects what we are solving.
- I read this in Science Learning, Science Teaching By Jerry Wellington, Gren Ireson but they reference Osbourne and Freyburg. I no longer have my copy the book so I cannot track down the primary reference without spending too much money. ↩
- The traditional and Algebraic Method. http://www.wikihow.com/Balance-Chemical-Equations ↩
Nicely put. Kudos.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian pharmacies
canadian pharmacies online
canada pharmacies online pharmacy
canada drugs
Nicely expressed certainly. !
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian drugstore canadian cialis canadian pharmacy online canada trust pharmacy canada
canadian drug stores online
drugs from canada
walgreens pharmacy
the canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
canada pharmacy online
Amazing quite a lot of beneficial knowledge!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian pharma companies aarp approved canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs online without doctor northwestpharmacy
canada meds
online rx pharmacy
internet pharmacy
canadian discount pharmacy
mail order pharmacies
best canadian mail order pharmacies
You definitely made the point.
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian pharmacy online canada canada pharmaceuticals online best online canadian pharcharmy canadian pharmacies-24h
online pharmacy
walmart pharmacy price check
walmart pharmacy price check
online prescription drugs
pharmacy online store
northwestpharmacy
This is nicely put. !
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
best canadian prescription prices canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs canada northwestpharmacy
no prescription pharmacy
prescription drug cost
discount prescription drugs online
canadian pharma companies
compare rx prices
pharmacies near me
Thank you! Valuable information.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
drug prices comparison canadian pharmacies that ship to us northwest pharmacy canadian pharmacies without an rx
canadian pharmacies
canada pharmacies without script
northwest pharmacy canada
online pharmacy no prescription needed
pharmacy canada
best online pharmacies no prescription
This is nicely expressed. !
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian drug canadian pharmacies online legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies canadian pharmacy online
canadian drugstore reviews
canadian rx
buying drugs canada
best online pharmacy
canadian pharmacy viagra
prescription drug cost
Kudos, Fantastic stuff.
http://talahicc.com/
prescription drug canadian drugs discount pharmacy online canadian online pharmacy
no prescription online pharmacy
canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian drugstore
meds online
canadadrugs
canadian pharmacy without prescription
Kudos! Very good stuff.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian cialis canadian online pharmacy best canadian prescription prices top rated canadian pharmacies online
buy prescription drugs without doctor
prescription drugs prices
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
best online international pharmacies
canadian rx
overseas pharmacy forum
Nicely put. With thanks!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian pharmacy 365 canada pharmaceutical online ordering discount pharmacy canada pharmaceuticals online
online pharmacies canada
web medical information
canada online pharmacies
no prior prescription required pharmacy
canadian drugstore reviews
online canadian discount pharmacy
You’ve made your stand pretty well!.
http://talahicc.com/
canada drug pharmacy canada pharmacy online discount pharmacy canadian pharcharmy
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
online pharmacy canada
internet pharmacy
cialis online
cialis online
pharmacy prices
Cheers, Valuable information.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
ed meds online canadian pharmacies that ship to us canadian drug canada pharmaceutical online ordering
mexican pharmacy online
top rated online canadian pharmacies
canada pharmacy no prescription
cheap canadian drugs
top rated online canadian pharmacies
canada drugs
You expressed it effectively.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
highest rated canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacy pharmacy prices canada drugs online
mexican pharmacies online
canadian pharmacy no prescription
canada online pharmacy
canadian drug
canadian discount pharmacy
canada drug prices
You have made your point very well!.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
cialis online global pharmacy canada online pharmacy canada drugs
discount prescription drug
canada drug prices
canadian drugstore
canadian pharmacy viagra
cialis canadian pharmacy
online pharmacy without a prescription
Regards! Good stuff!
http://talahicc.com/
drugs without prescription northwest pharmacy canada online pharmacy canadian online pharmacies
canadianpharmacy
prescription drugs without doctor approval
walgreens pharmacy
canadian pharmacies top best
canada pharmacies
rx pharmacy
Appreciate it! A good amount of advice!
https://nicktambone.com/
onlinecanadianpharmacy.com canada drug cialis canadian pharmacy online pharmacies canada
no prescription pharmacies
prescription drug
top rated online canadian pharmacies
canada meds
international pharmacy
canadian rx pharmacy online
Valuable info. With thanks!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
online prescription drugs london drugs canada pharmacy prices canadian pharmacies without an rx
canadian viagra
overseas pharmacy forum
mexican online pharmacies
visit poster’s website
canada drugs online pharmacy
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
Truly lots of awesome facts!
http://talahicc.com/
get prescription online canadian pharmacies without an rx no 1 canadian pharcharmy online online pharmacies of canada
online pharmacy no prescription
rx pharmacy
canadian drugstore
canadapharmacyonline com
board of pharmacy
onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
Seriously many of great facts!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
online rx pharmacy north west pharmacy canada compare prescription prices mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
online pharmacies canada
best online pharmacy
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
no prior prescription required pharmacy
get prescription online
best online canadian pharcharmy
You reported it fantastically.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
best price prescription drugs trust pharmacy canada canada pharmacy canadian pharmacies-24h
canadian prescription
pharmacy near me
prescription drugs without doctor approval
online pharmacy reviews
drugstore online
<a href="http://www.nationwidemarketing.com/blog/?form2mailerror&inquiry=Business+Development&fname=Patrickmow&lname=Patrickmow&email=jimmiepak%40gmail.com&company=google&phone1=83381146721&phone2=89767764275&phone3=86932752432&comments=You+reported+this+fantastically%21+https://nicktambone.com+canadian+mail+order+pharmacies+%3Ca+href=%22http://talahicc.com%22%3Ecanada+pharmacy+online%3C/a%3E+medication+costs+%3Ca+href=http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com%3Ecanadian+drugs%3C/a%3E?form2mailerror&inquiry=Business Development&fname=QuentinWer&lname=QuentinWer&email=zittel020eejf@songwriter.net&company=google&phone1=89176545125&phone2=84654865543&phone3=89685762628&comments= Terrific content. Many thanks! http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/ canadian rx london drugs canada canada pharmacy online no script canada drugs pharmacy price comparison canada pharmacy online reviews drugs online pharmacy prices compare canadian rx online pharmacy without prescription“>pharmacy price comparison
Wonderful facts. Thank you!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canadian drugstore reviews canadian pharmacies that ship to us buy online prescription drugs canada pharmacy
online pharmacy without a prescription
drugs without prescription
canadian pharmacy without prescription
online pharmacy no prescription
prescription drugs online without
best online pharmacies canada
Nicely put. Thank you.
https://nicktambone.com/
prescription drugs without doctor approval london drugs canada cheap canadian drugs canadian online pharmacies
internet pharmacy
prescription drugs online without doctor
online pharmacy no prescription
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
canadapharmacyonline.com
online drugstore
Helpful information. Thank you.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
mail order pharmacy canadian pharcharmy drug stores near me canada pharmacy online
pharmacies near me
compare prescription prices
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
approved canadian pharmacies online
canada drugs
trusted overseas pharmacies
You made the point.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian discount pharmacy top rated canadian pharmacies online pharmacy price comparison canadian pharmacy
canadian viagra
online rx pharmacy
best canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian pharmacy reviews
pharmacy online
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
Incredible a good deal of beneficial info.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canada drug pharmacy canadian online pharmacies canadian pharmacy without prescription canadian pharmacy online
canadian pharmacy online canada
canadadrugs.com pharmacy
pharmacy prescription
prescription online
canada pharmacy online no script
canadian online pharmacy reviews
You made your point!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
pharmacy cost comparison canadian cialis canadapharmacyonline com london drugs canada
prescription drugs canada
onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
legitimate online pharmacies
canadian mail order pharmacies
online pharmacy no prescription
canada drugs pharmacy
Nicely put. Regards.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian pharmacies canadian pharmaceuticals online canada pharmacies without script top rated canadian pharmacies online
global pharmacy canada
canadian meds
mexican pharmacy online
online canadian pharmacy
online canadian discount pharmacy
price prescription drugs
Kudos. Loads of write ups.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian pharmacies that ship to us canadian pharmacy online pharmacies in canada canada pharmaceutical online ordering
most reliable canadian pharmacies
canadapharmacyonline com
canadian drug stores online
canada pharmacies online
online pharmacy usa
discount pharmacy online
Nicely put, Cheers.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian drugstore reviews canadian viagra prescription drugs canada canada pharmacy online
online pharmacies no prescription
canadian pharmacy meds
safeway pharmacy
drug costs
drugs from canada
canadian prescriptions
Nicely put, Thanks.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canada meds canadian drugs overseas pharmacy forum online pharmacies of canada
mail order pharmacy
canadian rx
buy online prescription drugs
canada pharmacy online no script
canada online pharmacy
pharmacy prescription
Nicely put, Many thanks.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
get prescription online canadianpharmacy pharmacy price compare canada pharmacy
drugs from canada
canadapharmacy com
buy cialis
prescription price comparison
online rx pharmacy
mexican pharmacies online
Whoa lots of wonderful advice.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
online drugstore canadian online pharmacies rx online canada drugs online
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian pharmacies online
prescription cost
pharmacy prices
best online pharmacies canada
rx online
Cheers. Excellent information.
http://talahicc.com/
online prescription drugs global pharmacy canada visit poster’s website canadian pharmacy
no prescription online pharmacy
discount pharmaceuticals
top rated online canadian pharmacies
online drugs
web medical information
mail order pharmacies
Nicely put. Thanks a lot!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
overseas pharmacies top rated canadian pharmacies online legitimate online pharmacies canada drug
board of pharmacy
cialis canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
best online pharmacies canada
international pharmacies that ship to the usa
online pharmacies canada
You stated it terrifically!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canada pharmacy online orders canadian pharmacies compare prescription prices trust pharmacy canada
canadian pharmacy online canada
canadian mail order pharmacies
cheap prescription drugs
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
walgreens pharmacy
visit poster’s website
Thank you! Lots of stuff.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
us pharmacy no prior prescription canadian pharmacies-24h pharmacy canada global pharmacy canada
canada pharmacies without script
drug costs
get prescription online
cialis canadian pharmacy
pain meds online without doctor prescription
discount pharmacy online
Terrific info, Thank you.
http://talahicc.com/
prescription drugs online without doctor canadian pharmacies without an rx prescription cost comparison canada drugs
highest rated canadian pharmacies
24 hour pharmacy
canadian drug
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
canada drugs
Wow plenty of terrific information!
http://talahicc.com/
canadian pharmacy online canada canadian drugs canadian online pharmacy canadian pharmacy
northwest pharmacy canada
discount pharmacy
canadian pharcharmy online
ed meds online
canada drug
canadian drug stores online
Terrific information. With thanks!
http://talahicc.com/
canadian mail order pharmacies online pharmacies canada drugstore online canadian pharmacy online
mail order pharmacies
canada pharmacy online orders
prescription online
canadian prescription
online prescription drugs
prescription cost comparison
Really all kinds of excellent info!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
buy prescription drugs online north west pharmacy canada highest rated canadian pharmacies canadian pharcharmy
canada pharmacy no prescription
online prescription drugs
buy prescription drugs online
canadian drugstore reviews
ed meds online
buying prescription drugs canada
Terrific forum posts. Appreciate it.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
online pharmacy usa canadian online pharmacy online canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy
canada drugs online
canadian drug store
online canadian pharcharmy
canadian pharma companies
canada pharmacies online
canada pharmacies without script
You actually revealed this fantastically!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
visit poster’s website canadian drugs online pharmacy usa canadianpharmacy
mexican online pharmacies
buy cialis
pharmacies near me
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
pharmacy online
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
You actually suggested this well.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadian drugs without prescription canada pharmaceuticals online canada online pharmacies canadian pharcharmy
discount prescription drug
no prescription pharmacy
canada meds
prescription price comparison
cheap prescription drugs
canadian prescriptions
Many thanks. I like this.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian pharmacy online northwestpharmacy canadian pharmacy online canada canadian cialis
mexican pharmacies
canadian online pharmacy reviews
prescription drugs online without
cheap drugs online
discount pharmacy online
canada pharmacy online orders
Many thanks, A good amount of information.
http://talahicc.com/
canadian pharmacy viagra brand canadian pharmacies that ship to us cheap prescription drugs canada pharmacy online
canadian pharcharmy online
safe canadian online pharmacies
prescription drugs prices
canada drugs online
online pharmacy canada
cheap canadian drugs
Amazing information. Many thanks.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian pharmacy king top rated canadian pharmacies online canadian prescription canada drugs
buy prescription drugs from canada
mexican pharmacies online
medical information online
medical information online
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian pharmacies
Thanks, I enjoy it!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
prescription online canadian pharmacies pharmacy online store canada pharmacy online
canadian online pharmacy
online pharmacy without a prescription
mexican pharmacy online
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
cheap drugs online
online pharmacy usa